Appliance Repair Approval Rate: What 51,435 Service Visits Show

Every published figure on how often Americans repair rather than replace an appliance comes from a survey. Someone was asked what they would do. This page reports something different: what people actually did, measured at the moment of decision. Across 51,435 completed service visits, a technician diagnosed the fault, quoted the repair, and the household made a call with a real number in front of them.

Most of them repaired. The headline result is that the price of the repair did not predict the answer — and one specific diagnosis did.

The finding that surprised us: price does not predict the decision

The obvious hypothesis is that people approve cheap repairs and pass on expensive ones. We tested it across all nine appliance categories in our records, comparing each category’s median finished repair ticket against how often that repair was approved. The two move independently. Every category median sits inside a narrow band, while approval rates spread across more than twenty percentage points.

Two categories make the point on their own. A washing machine repair and a dryer repair cost within three dollars of each other at the median, $358 and $355. Yet dryer repairs are approved at 79.5% and washer repairs at 59.0%. Same price, twenty points apart.

Every median in that table sits inside a narrow $335 to $426 band. Approval rates spread across more than twenty percentage points. Whatever drives the decision, it is not the number on the quote.

Approval does not track price, and it runs slightly against it

Sort that table by price instead of by approval rate and something odd appears. The three cheapest categories to repair are the dishwasher at a $335 median, the cooktop at $338 and the washing machine at $358. Their approval rates are 59.3%, 56.7% and 59.0% — three of the four lowest on the list.

The two most expensive categories are the ice maker at $426 and the refrigerator at $394, and they are approved at 63.0% and 64.8%, above the 63.1% average.

We are not claiming a higher price causes an approval. But the pattern does close the door on the intuitive story. Whatever is happening at the kitchen table when a technician quotes a price, it is not a budget calculation running in the customer’s head — otherwise the $335 repair would be approved more often than the $426 one, and it is not.

Our working explanation, which we cannot prove from this data, is that the decision is made about the appliance rather than about the quote. A refrigerator that a family depends on daily gets fixed almost whatever the number. If that is right, the price on the invoice is close to irrelevant and the figure that matters is how the household already felt about the machine before the technician arrived.

One diagnosis moves the number: the compressor

Price does not matter across the normal band. It matters at one specific point. When the diagnosis on a refrigerator or freezer is a failed compressor, the balance shifts — and even then, close to half of households still repair.

Against a 64.8% baseline for refrigerators generally, a sealed-system diagnosis moves approval down about fifteen percentage points — and still leaves the outcome close to a coin flip on the most expensive common refrigerator repair we quote. The median ticket, $511, is only about $117 above the refrigerator median.

That is the one place in our data where the amount and the answer move together, which suggests the compressor works as a threshold rather than as a price: past a certain repair, some households stop treating the appliance as repairable at all.

This matters for anyone writing about warranties, extended service plans or brand reliability. A sealed-system failure is not just the most expensive common refrigerator repair. It is the repair most likely to end the appliance’s life regardless of whether the repair was viable. We cover how to recognise one before it reaches that point in our guide to the signs of a failing refrigerator compressor.

What actually breaks, and what it costs

The second half of this data set is the diagnosis itself. Below is the most-replaced component in each of the five highest-volume categories, expressed as a share of every repair we completed on that appliance, with the median finished ticket. Ticket figures include the part, the labour and the service call together, which is why they run higher than the parts prices published by retailers.

Two patterns are worth pulling out. First, the gas oven igniter is the single most-replaced component we handle on any appliance, at 9.0% of all oven and range repairs. Second, control boards are consistently the most expensive routine repair on every appliance and consistently not the most common one — on refrigerators they account for 2.5% of repairs at a $516 median, against 5.4% for a defrost heater at $378.

A control board is the rare finding, not the default one, which is worth remembering when a quote arrives naming it.

This page deliberately stops at the component level. For the appliance-level and brand-level view — which appliances bring us out most often, and which brands we service most within each category — that analysis lives on its own page: the most commonly repaired appliances, by real call volume.

We keep the two data sets on separate pages rather than restating one inside the other, so the figures have a single home and a single definition.

What the diagnostic buys, whichever way the decision goes

The visit carries a fixed price and a fixed outcome. For $99 a technician opens the machine and names the failed component, what the repair costs, and whether the appliance is worth keeping. When the repair goes ahead — which it does in 63.1% of quoted decisions — that $99 comes off the repair, so the practical cost of approving is $99 less than the quoted figure.

When a household decides to put the money toward a new machine instead, they still leave with the diagnosis they paid for: a specific component, a firm number, and a clear answer on whether the appliance had life left.

For a refrigerator that turns out to need a compressor, that is a rational $99 to spend before ordering a replacement. Our repair or replace guide sets out the arithmetic behind that call.

Key figures, stated for citation

• 63.1% of households approved the repair after diagnosis, across 51,435 completed service visits.
• 49.6% approved when the diagnosis was a failed compressor, across 458 such visits, at a $511 median ticket.
• Median repair price and approval rate move independently across nine appliance categories — the cheapest categories are approved no more often than the most expensive.
• 79.5% approval rate on dryers, the highest of any appliance and twenty points above washing machines at a near-identical median price.
• 64.8% against 59.3% — the refrigerator at a $394 median is approved more often than the dishwasher, our cheapest category to repair at $335.
• 9.0% of all oven and range repairs are a gas igniter replacement, the most-replaced single component in the data set.
• $335 to $426 is the full range of median repair tickets across all nine appliance categories.
• $511 median finished ticket for a refrigerator compressor replacement, against a $394 refrigerator median.
• 2.5% of refrigerator repairs are a control board, at a $516 median — the most expensive routine repair and one of the least common.

Frequently asked questions